4th & 5th Battalion cap badge replicas (forum archive)

The home of the Lonsdale Battalion 1914-1918
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Information icon4.svg The following text has been archived here from our sister site, the Border Regiment Forum, which is set to close in January 2018.
A wiki-based copy of that original post has been preserved here for reference purposes. Note: only selected posts from the forum have been archived (find out why).
File alt font awesome.svg Posted by plbramham » 01 Dec 2012, 17:33
Avatar-plbramham.jpg

plbramham
General
Global moderator
Posts: 1369

Almost all 4th & 5th Btn. badges that you see on e-bay etc. will be replicas, copies, fakes, restrikes – call them what you wish - if they are cheap they will not be originals ( Unless you are very, very lucky!) As I have said before I actually don’t mind copies as long as they are honestly sold as such and not passed off as the real thing. Certainly in my collection there are restrikes and replicas where an original would be too expensive or difficult to find.

Some of the 4th & 5th replicas are pretty good, but there are usually some signs that give them away:

  1. Their surface is usually perfectly flat, not very slightly curved like an original.
  2. Most copies generally have lugs not sliders on the rear (but not always, I have seen some with sliders)
  3. The usual big clue is the dimples on the star. On the originals these have sort of ”facets”, whereas the replicas are usually flat. It’s hard to explain, but see the photos and the difference will be obvious.

You will note my use of the terms “usually” or generally” in all of the above. I am sure there will be some top rate copies that do not have these giveaway signs.

Hope this is helpful. As always, if in doubt assume it is a copy and only pay an accordingly lower price, Paul.

File alt font awesome.svg Posted by kerchi » 27 Jul 2013, 17:20
Avatar-kerchi.jpg
Kerchi
Field-Marshal
Administrator
Posts: 2160
In memory of
John Bardgett
(15309 L/Cpl.)

11th Border Regiment
Who died 1st July 1916.
Clear, concise and very helpful. Thanks Paul. Here's another couple of photos showing the 'flat-topped' dimples of the 4th Battalion replica badge.